Spirit Sleuths

A Chicago Public Library Best of the Best Books 2024

★ "Sibert Honor winner Gail Jarrow (Spooked!; The Poison Eaters) turns her astute attention to the phenomenon of spiritualism and the investigators who worked to disprove the con. Jarrow's remarkable ability to transform meticulous research into a gripping narrative once again results in a nonfiction work that will transfix readers of all ages...Jarrow continues to work magic in Spirit Sleuths, making certain that young readers can find history accessible, exciting, and surprising." —Shelf Awareness, starred review

★ "A natural and riveting follow-up to Jarrow’s Spooked and The Amazing Harry Kellar, her previous books about debunking hoaxes and the supernatural. In concise, approachable chapters, the author details the origins of Spiritualism, its popularity and most well-known practitioners, and the sleuths who dedicated their lives to disproving the methods and beliefs that made it popular...The book’s emphasis on how these mediums and psychics used smoke and mirrors to swindle people serves as an excellent tool to teach young ­readers about the dangers of misinformation. The spacious white pages and photo-filled design add to the work’s readability...The 25 pages of back matter are a librarian’s dream and include an author’s note, timeline, glossary, index, source notes, further ­reading, and more. The indomitable Jarrow crafts another enthralling ­narrative of nonfiction that will mesmerize curious readers and serve as an exemplar for educators and ­researchers." —School Library Journal, starred review

"Jarrow's remarkable ability to transform meticulous research into a gripping narrative once again results in a nonfiction work that will transfix readers of all ages...Jarrow includes detailed insets throughout the book that explain how mediums performed their trickery and how the investigators uncovered the secrets. The book also includes reproductions of news headlines, photographs, and other ephemera from the corresponding time periods. For those craving more, extensive resources appear in the book's back matter. Jarrow continues to work magic in Spirit Sleuths, making certain that young readers can find history accessible, exciting, and surprising." —Shelf Awareness

"During the height of spiritualism from the 1840s to the 1920s, many so-called mediums fooled their audiences with illusions disproven by some of themost talented stage magicians, including Harry Houdini. But Jarrow’s exploration of what was proven to be fake is also conscious of the true hold spiritualism had on people who believed inthe great beyond, cementing the movement as a fascinating moment in cultural history, especially in the U.S. In this title, the wheels of Spiritualism are shown being sped by crowds and slowed by individuals, making for a page-turner of a spooky history book." —Booklist

"In this thoroughly researched study, [Jarrow] singles out two investigators in particular for their persistence: Harry Houdini, who made exposures of séance fakery a regular part of his stage act, and his protégé Rose Mackenberg, a tough-minded private detective and master of disguise who worked with victims and law enforcement to shut down spirit scams for decades after Houdini’s premature death...she [offers] insights into the clever techniques used by both hoaxers and hoax-busters, as well as a timely case study on the persistence of irrational belief in the face of logic and overwhelming negative evidence...Penetrating and provocative." —Kirkus Reviews

"A mesmerizing read that not only details the rise of spiritualism, and the role Houdini played in debunking it, but implores readers to rely on critical thinking skills to evade deception." —Publishers Weekly

“The subject matter is rife with drama and intrigue…Photographs, newspaper articles, and advertisements, however, effectively set the historical stage while also conveying the spiritualists’ theatrics….The explanations of and secrets behind some of the more common deceptions might have readers trying their own hand at acts of illusions.” –Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books

“This intriguing deep dive into an underexplored period of history shows readers how obvious lies can cement into passionately held beliefs that can stand up to scrutiny if the believer is sufficiently motivated.” –The Horn Book